I gave it a 4 for things that bothered me:
--I felt like there were a few things that were included that would have mortified EE - such as us being told that she "peed herself" upon a meeting with the head lady of her boarding school. Not sure that was necessary.
--I felt like the language used to describe the Waodani couples was a little bit too earthy for a biography of this distinguished lady.
--And just because Elisabeth Elliot, in a depth of frustration, wrote "To hell with zeal!" - it was gratuitous to use that as a chapter title, to draw people in with "Elisabeth Elliot said WHAT?"
--I saw a few places where the punctation did not appear to be properly edited.
--I also felt like the author inserted herself in a few places where she could have stepped aside.
But overall, this is a thoughtful, detailed work, and I am eagerly awaiting Volume II (and wish that the fact that this book was Volume I had been stated as part of the title).
1 comment:
I'm reading this now. I'm at the part where she and Jim love each other but don't think it's God's will to marry.
I didn't realize this was a Part 1 until I started it, and I was dismayed, too. Not that I mind getting enough information to fill two books (hopefully just two), but I wish they had brought that detail out more.
I very much agree about some unnecessary information being included that would have mortified EE (haven't gotten to the Waodani couples yet). One takeaway--I understand why some famous people destroy their letters and diaries! I'm glad EE didn't, but I wish the author was a little more judicious in what she shared from them.
Post a Comment